A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF EFFICIENCY AND ITS DETERMINANTS IN ISLAMIC, CONVENTIONAL, AND SOCIALLY RESPONSIBLE BANKS

Download This Article

Abstract

This study empirically estimates efficiency and its determinants in 190 Islamic (IBs), conventional (CBs), and socially responsible banks (SRBs) in 22 countries during the period 2005-2012. The study first uses non-parametric approaches to estimate the efficiency measures (scale efficiency (SE), technical efficiency-constant returns to scale (CRS), and technical efficiency-variable returns to scale (VRS)) and second employs ordinary least squares, fixed effects, random effects, and TOBIT models to get the efficiency determinants. The findings indicate that the average efficiency is 0.966, 0.952, and 0.983 for the SE, CRS, and VRS, respectively. However, efficiency measures show that the SRBs are most efficient banks whereas, the least efficiency scores archived by Islamic banks. Islamic bank efficiency is positively correlated with size, loan intensity, ROA, inflation rates, market capitalization and financial crisis. However, conventional banks’ TE and CRS efficiency are positively and significantly correlated with size, ROA, and market capitalization, while their VRS efficiency is negatively and significantly related to capital ratio, age and GDP. In addition, SRBs’ efficiency is increased by size, capital ratio, loan intensity, ROA, foreign ownership, domestic ownership, inflation and financial crisis. Furthermore, the financial crisis affects the SE and CRS efficiency measures in Islamic banks while socially responsible banks SE efficiency measure is positively affected by the financial crisis, which means that socially responsible banks were stabled and resisted during the crisis period. Finally, there is no significant correlation between financial crisis and efficiency indictors in conventional banks during the period.

Keywords: Islamic Banks, Conventional Banks, Socially Responsible Banks, Ethical Banks, Data Envelopment Analysis, Bank’s Efficiency, Global Financial Crisis

How to cite this paper: Alharthi, M. (2016). A comparative study of efficiency and its determinants in Islamic, conventional, and socially responsible banks. Corporate Ownership & Control, 13(4-3), 470-482. https://doi.org/10.22495/cocv13i4c3p6