MODES OF GOVERNANCE AND THE USE OF COST INFORMATION: A COMPARATIVE STUDY BETWEEN BRAZILIAN AND BRITISH HOSPITALS

Download This Article

Marcio Augusto Gonçalves ORCID logo, Reynaldo Maia Muniz ORCID logo, Marcia Mascarenhas Alemão ORCID logo, Lucas Maia dos Santos ORCID logo

https://doi.org/10.22495/cocv7i4c3p2

Abstract

Cost information can be considered an important tool to benchmarking, planning and control, improving the management of expenditures, mainly in a public institution that are known by having scarce resources. This study was carried out to investigate different modes of governance within Brazilian and British hospitals and the usefulness of cost information in terms of managerial plannig and control. The research was conducted by cross cultural analysis, using several statistical methods for measuring organisation characteristics, seeking to gain a deeper understanding of the profile of both hospitals and respondents. This study showed the dominance of hierarchy and clan as being the most relevant modes of governance in Brazilian and British hospitals. This discussion is relevant considering the congruence level of goals and the ambiguity level of performance measurement. Also, it defines which form of governance is more predominant. The exploratory and quantitative survey methods were used to test the research questions. After conducting a survey using a structured questionnaire, semi-structured interviews with middle managers at chosen case study hospitals were undertaken. In the cases analyzed, it was possible to identify a significant difference between the use of cost information in hospitals, allowing inferences between different modes of governance. The lack of studies about the use of cost information in planning and control regarding public hospitals impedes any other comparison or assessment considering empirical data. One of the objectives of this paper was to generate initial material for future researchers. Besides, the knowledge about the current scenario of the usefulness of cost information mainly in planning and control is relevant when associated with modes of governance.

Keywords: Modes of Governance, Cost Information Usefulness, Healthcare System, Cross Cultural Study

How to cite this paper:Gonçalves, M. A., Maia Muniz, R., Mascarenhas Alemão, M., Maia dos Santos, L. (2010). Modes of governance and the use of cost information: a comparative study between Brazilian and British hospitals. Corporate Ownership & Control, 7(4-3), 365-379. https://doi.org/10.22495/cocv7i4c3p2