Sustainability ratings and corporate control: Debacle of shareholder over stakeholder theory

Download This Article

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Abstract

Corporate sustainability rating is frequently observed by different stakeholders, thereby finding interest in academic studies as well. Shareholders of sustainable-companies respond to different types of stock market news, be it financial or non-financial news. Announcements relating to ratings obtained by sustainability-compliant businesses appear to create anticipation in the mind of the investor. If these announcements are viewed by investors with interest, then it can have a greater implication for corporate governance and control and the corporate leaders can find a clear path to resolve the much debated “shareholder” versus “stakeholder” view in decision-making. This paper aims to explain whether or not the declaration of sustainability ratings contributes to the stock market reaction in emerging markets such as India. Short-run event analysis was carried out on a set of selected BSE listed companies following sustainable practice (2017-2019) and the entire data set was split into categories of the upgrade, downgrade, no change, and no ratings. The study results show that the announcement of sustainability ratings is not regarded by investors with a great deal of interest and there is inherent indifference to such news in the stock market. These findings are relevant for stock exchanges, investors, and corporate control as it raises a serious issue of rethinking stakeholder awareness levels, which in an emerging economy such as India currently seem to be in a nascent stage. In order to meet the stakeholders interested in the process of business becoming sustainable corporate leaders through proper governance should explore ways and means to approach sustainability in a more systematic way.

Keywords: Corporate Control, Conflict of Interest, ESG Ratings, Event Study, Shareholder Theory, Stakeholder Theory

Authors’ individual contribution: Conceptualization – S.Y.; Methodology – C.M.; Software – C.M.; Validation – S.Y.; Formal Analysis – C.M.; Investigation – S.Y.; Writing – Original Draft – S.Y.; Writing – Review & Editing – S.Y.; Visualization – C.M.

Declaration of conflicting interests: The Authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.

JEL Classification: C53, C58, G12, G17

Received: 02.10.2020
Accepted: 30.11.2020
Published online: 02.12.2020

How to cite this paper: Malik, C., & Yadav, S. (2020). Sustainability ratings and corporate control: Debacle of shareholder over stakeholder theory [Special issue]. Corporate Ownership & Control, 18(1), 408-422. https://doi.org/10.22495/cocv18i1siart14